Title: The Unfulfilled Promise of Modular Smartphones: Reflecting on Project Ara and the Future of Modularity in Consumer Tech
Subtitle: How Fairphone and Framework are Pioneering the Way Forward
By Pierre Herubel
In a tech landscape that often favors sleek design and glued-down components, the dream of modular smartphones, championed by Google and its subsidiary Motorola, remains unfulfilled even a decade after its conception. Project Ara, which aimed to create customizable smartphones with swappable modules for easy repairs and upgrades, ultimately met its demise in September 2016. Despite Motorola’s attempt to carry the torch with hot-swappable back panels on their devices, the market’s lack of interest mirrored the fate of the once beloved BlackBerry.
Modular consumer tech has struggled to gain traction, as evident in Razer’s failed attempt with Project Christine, a modular gaming PC platform. While personal computers offer some level of upgradability, the concept of modular consumer tech has not translated well into other devices. As technology evolves, flagship smartphones become less upgradable, and basic features such as removable batteries and microSD card slots have become increasingly rare.
While the trend towards slimmer, more powerful smartphones has its benefits, the lack of flexibility and the need for professional repairs result in a less environmentally friendly approach. A phone with modular components could potentially reduce electronic waste as users can simply replace outdated or defective modules instead of purchasing an entirely new device. However, the challenge lies in convincing consumers to buy into the concept, as it requires a certain level of technical knowledge and foresight.
Nevertheless, the rise of DIY tech enthusiasts and the growing push for right-to-repair initiatives suggest that there is an audience interested in modular technology. Fairphone, a company dedicated to eco-friendly smartphones, incorporates modularity into its design to enable easy upgrades and repairs. While not as customizable as Project Ara envisioned, Fairphone challenges the one-time-use mentality with its commitment to sustainability. Other manufacturers, such as Samsung and OnePlus, would benefit from following suit.
On the laptop front, Framework laptops have successfully implemented true modularity. These devices offer a basic laptop frame that allows users to customize and swap components such as keyboards, GPUs, and ports. Framework laptops not only cater to the desire for customizable laptops but also empower users to perform their own repairs through plug ‘n’ play module swapping. While they may not appeal to everyone, tech enthusiasts have taken notice.
Fairphone and Framework serve as shining examples of the possibilities of modularity in consumer tech. While mainstream modular smartphones may not become a reality, the industry should re-explore the concept to meet the demand for more sustainable and user-friendly devices. At the very least, let us have the option to swap out our smartphone batteries. The future holds potential, and the lessons learned from Project Ara should guide manufacturers towards a more modular and environmentally conscious future.
[Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publication.]
I have over 10 years of experience in the cryptocurrency industry and I have been on the list of the top authors on LinkedIn for the past 5 years.